Lately, I’ve seen people saying things like “a 4-week-old sourdough starter is too young” to justify someone’s problems with their bread or starters. This statement is just wrong and very discouraging for new bakers, or people on a budget who can’t just throw flour every day for feedings.
Two weeks (as a rule of thumb) should suffice to have an active and powerful starter. Let alone 4 weeks!. In fact, depending on the method you used to create your starter, you might be able to make bread in just a week!
Chances are that the age of your sourdough starter has nothing to do with the problems you might be having. In this series of posts I’m going to delve into the science of your starter so you can troubleshoot whenever you need. Although, I hope you only need to troubleshoot it once!
WHAT DEFINES THE STRENGTH OF YOUR SOURDOUGH STARTER?
It’s not time, it’s THE NUMBER OF ACTIVE BACTERIA present in your starter. If your sourdough starter is not ready after 2 weeks (and depending on the method, maybe just a week), your feeding schedule probably needs adjustment. Either you’re following a fixed schedule instead of refreshing the starter when is ready, or you’re using the wrong ratio and not introducing enough nourishment for all the microorganisms to reproduce. Let’s dive into it:
BASICS OF SOURDOUGH BACTERIA
Bacteria in sourdough follow a 4-phase growth curve: Lag phase, exponential phase, stationary phase, and death phase, (For more of this go check this post where I tell you all about it). During the lag phase, they’re not multiplying yet; they’re just checking the environment and synthesizing the proteins and products they need to start multiplying (growing). At this stage, whichever ratio you used to feed your sourdough starter introduced some nutrients for the bacteria.
The second phase involves the exponential growth we’re all familiar with; the duration of the second phase(how much the starter is going to grow) purely depends on how much food there is available for the bacteria. Or better said, how many grams of food per bacteria were introduced. Let me explain:
Imagine a family of 4 people that has 4 cupcakes; they get one cupcake per person, they will run out of cupcakes fast, and they are not going to get a lot of weight because they only ate one cupcake each. Now let’s say we have the same family, and instead of 4, we have 12 cupcakes; then they get 3 cupcakes per person, it’s going to take longer to finish them all, and they will gain more weight because there was more food, right?
Same with your sourdough starter! Smaller ratios mean that the food is going to run out faster, and the growth (bacteria multiplying) is going to take place for a shorter period of time. Now let’s say you used a 1:3:3 ratio (like the family), the bacteria have a lot more food, so they’ll be eating for longer; therefore, it’ll take a longer time to finish all food.
What happens after the bacteria eats all the food? Bacteria multiply as long as they have food (energy), once all the food is depleted, they can stay active for a while, this is what we call the “peak” (the stationary phase), and the reason we say this is the best moment to use your sourdough starter is that it’s when there’s the largest number ALIVE AND ACTIVE bacteria.
After the peak, bacteria start going dormant; some die too (death phase). When using a 100% hydration starter (Keep in mind that gluten-free flours behave a bit differently because of the lack of gluten), this moment usually occurs at the same time the gluten network starts breaking down. That’s when we see the starter collapsing (there are more variables involved in this, but for now, let’s imagine the kitchen is at around 20C, not too cold, not too warm, so neither the bacteria growth nor the gluten in the starter is compromised because of the temperature).
WHY IS MY SOURDOUGH STARTER NOT DOUBLING?
One of the main problems I see is that people refresh their sourdough starters based on time (fixed schedule) and not when it’s ready. So when you take part of your starter out too early and introduce new flour and water, what you’re really doing is reducing the number of active bacteria before they have a chance to multiply. What you’re doing is bringing more cupcakes to the family but taking away a few members, so yes, there are lots of cupcakes, but not enough people to eat them in a reasonable time. And the more you do this, the more you feed your starter too early, the more bacteria you’re taking away, and the more you’re reducing the fermentative power of your starter by introducing unfermented flour. It might get to a point where the number of bacteria is so low that you might not see any growth in maybe 12 hours! (Even though they’re still working hard multiplying!)
Basically, you are keeping your sourdough starter in a continuous lag phase or a very early exponential phase.
HOW CAN I FIX MY SOURDOUGH STARTER?
Easy, just WAIT!, leave the starter at room temperature for a whole day; it’s not going to grow mold, and it’s not going to go bad (if it does, then your starter was already contaminated with other microorganisms). If the problem is a very low number of bacteria, they need time to get out of the lag phase and get well into the exponential phase. Wait, and most likely, you’ll see some growth, maybe in the form of small bubbles, maybe you can smell it, or maybe you can even see the dough growing a tiny bit.
If you don’t keep a large amount of starter (less than 40 g total), you can add more flour and water without discarding anything and wait for it to grow again; then you can start with regular feedings. If you keep a larger amount, you can discard some and refresh it. At this stage, since the problem was (most likely) the low number of bacteria, you don’t want to give it too much food all at once because that might take too long to ferment, and you’re going to get frustrated. I would aim for a 1:1:1 ratio for a couple of feeds until you see obvious signs of activity and the starter growing. Then wait for it to peak, and decide which ratio works better for your situation.
Wrapping up
Feeding ratios are another big thing when it comes to sourdough starters, in part II I’ll tackle feeding ratios and some outrageous advice I’ve seen people tell newbies. Things like “if your starter doesn’t double in 4 hours then it’s not powerful enough”. If you’ve heard that before, stay tuned! And if you have questions write them in the comments so I can try to respond as best as I can.
You can find me on Instagram, Facebook, and Pinterest, and you can also subscribe to my Youtube channel.
Happy baking!
This post contains affiliate links and any sales made through such links will reward me a small commission – at no extra cost for you – that allows me to keep running this blog.
The science of your sourdough starter
Welcome to a new section of my blog: Bread Science Fridays! In this section I will be indulging on my nerd side and talk about the science of many things behind your beautiful bakes. This week’s post is dedicated to our beloved sourdough starters and the science behind them!
Ever since the pandemic started, more and more people jumped into sourdough. So, I thought it could be fun to explain scientifically what happens when you feed your starter (or build your levain).
A sourdough starter it’s just a culture of microorganisms that are alive and perform their own biological activity. These cultures are composed, mostly, by different strains of lactic acid bacteria (LAB), saccharomyces yeasts, and some candida yeasts among others.
In this post, you will learn the phases your starter goes through during a feeding cycle, why using your starter at its peak of activity is important, and the science behind it!
A couple of things about biology
In microbiology, a strain of a certain type of microorganism is like a subtype of named microorganism. For example, the lactic acid bacteria type would be the lactobacillus but there are many subtypes (Strains). Lactobacillus Acidophilus, Lactobacillus Sanfranciscensis, Lactobacillus Reuteri… They’re all LAB but with some differences (from shape to optimum living conditions).
Each strain has its specific optimum living conditions. That is the optimum temperature, water activity, pH… that will make the fermentation rate the fastest. The fact that a microorganism is “happy” at 28C, for example, doesn’t mean that it cannot perform its biological activities at 29C or at 20C. It means that the performance will not be the best. As you know, it slows down at cold temperatures. However, it’s higher temperature that pose a threat to the microorganisms. Too high temperatures will inhibit and eventually kill the bacteria.
The bacterial growth curve
Bacteria, as living organisms, grow, multiply, and die. The reason our sourdough starter is resilient is not because the bacteria are indestructible, its’ because there are millions of them and not all of them are the same age. They are in different growth phases. While maybe most of the bacteria are dying, some might have just been born.
Bacteria and yeast multiply by dividing themselves into two. 1 becomes 2, 2 become 4, 4 become 16, etc. This mechanism is called binary fission. Therefore, their growth is exponential. In microbiology, this growth is depicted using growth curves.
Bacterial growth curves are specific for each strain of bacteria in a specific set of conditions (Changing the temperature will change the curve). In these curves we can see the 4 phases bacteria undergo from the moment they’re born to the moment they die. A generic bacterial growth curve would look similar to this one:
Our starter will follow this growth cycle too. Understanding what happens in each phase will help us understand our starter and when we should use it for baking to prevent a excess of sourness
The phases explained
Phase 1: Lag phase. This is the very beginning of the curve. At this stage, the microorganisms have enough nutrients and are active but they’re still not multiplying. What they’re doing is synthesizing proteins and getting things ready to start the division. It’s also an adaptation period to the culture conditions.
Phase 2: Exponential phase. Once things are ready, the bacteria start multiplying (by binary fission). The metabolic activity on this stage is high and increases as the number of bacteria increases (optimal growth). Some bacteria might die too, but overall, there are more bacteria multiplying than dying.
Phase 3: Stationary phase. This phase is a plateau the bacteria reach because of the depletion of nutrients or accumulation of waste (the acids they produce can inhibit their own activity). Less food means less activity and therefore fewer bacteria dividing. At this point, the growth and death rates are equal, and the overall number of microorganisms remains constant.
Phase 4: Death phase. At this point, nutrients are decreasing and bacteria continue to produce waste from their biological activities (bacterial poop if you may 😉 ). The environment becomes harsh and bacteria start dying (some also go dormant). In this phase, the death rate is faster than the growth rate, so the overall number of microorganisms decreases.
Theoretical growth: it portrays how the curve would continue growing if the bacteria had an endless supply of nutrients.
When you add sourdough starter to your dough, the exponential phase will be much longer because the bacteria:nutrients ratio is much larger. The curve would, to certain extent, follow the theoretical growth because there are lots of nutrients!
How does this apply to your sourdough starter?
Knowing in which phase your starter is, will be very helpful for your baking. The fermentative power of your sourdough will depend on the phase of the cycle it is on, and it is different in each phase.
Although the by-products of the fermentation are essentially the same in each phase, the aromas developed in the bread will be substantially different because every time we take some starter and mix it with flour and water, we’re resetting the growth curve. It starts again in the lag phase.
And depending on the length of the lag phase, more/fewer aromas will build up in the dough. Ideally, we should use the starter at its peak of activity. Which means the lag phase will be shorter.
But, what exactly is the peak of activity and what’s the best way to know it? Let’s dive deeper into this!
The peak of activity and what it means
When it comes to sourdough it’s common to talk about the “peak of activity”; we understand that it represents the optimum conditions of the starter and it will work faster if it’s at the peak.
Based on the growth curve I showed you before, it’s easier to see that the peak of activity happens at the end of the exponential phase and throughout the stationary phase. During that time the sourdough starter is very active because 1) the number of alive bacteria is high because they still have lots of nutrients and 2) they’re all used to the environmental conditions, well past the lag phase where they’d be creating “waste” but not multiplying and growing.
Obviously, we are not going to do a bunch of experiments to determine when we should bake. However, once we’re familiar with our starters, we know when they reach the peak of activity (more on this later). We can, then, differentiate 3 stages in our starter:
1.- Before the peak of activity
2.- At the peak of activity
3.- Past the peak of activity
The dough fermentation will definitely be affected by the stage of the starter. Let’s analyze it a bit more how that translates into flavor and aromas of our bread and how it’s related to the growth curve.
The starter has not doubled yet after the last feeding
When we refresh our starter (or when we’re building the levain) what we’re doing is resetting the bacterial growth curve. The microorganisms need to adapt to the new conditions first (lag phase) and then eat and multiply (exponential phase).
If your starter has not even doubled since the last feeding, the microorganisms didn’t have enough time to reproduce; they are at the very beginning of the exponential phase and there is still a low number of them.
Basically, you’d be adding just flour and water with a low number of bacteria.
At this point, the fermentative power of the starter is not high enough because there aren’t enough bacteria to perform the job; which means your dough will need a longer time to ferment. This can be detrimental to your dough because longer fermentation times might lead to a more acidic dough.
Not only that, but you could also risk destroying the gluten network. If the fermentation is much longer than it should, your flour might not be able to resist and the gluten strands will start to deteriorate.
Maybe, flavor-wise, the bread turns out as tangy as you like it, but the structure could be compromised.
The starter has reached or almost reached the peak
People recommend using the starter at its peak of activity, but what many don’t know it’s why exactly this is the best condition for sourdough baking. Spoiler alert: It has nothing to do with your culture being hungry.
At least, not in the literal sense of the word, because the microorganisms eat when they have food, and when they don’t, they just change their metabolism pathway and go into “survival mode” (they become dormant). That’s why they can survive in the fridge for months without being fed, or they can be frozen or dried.
Every time we change the environment of the microorganisms, they need to adapt to the new conditions; so, they have to go through the lag phase again. If the starter has passed the peak or if it’s too early in the feeding cycle, this adaptation period is going to be longer. Either because the microorganisms need to get ready to increase the colony, or because they went into survival mode.
The idea of using the starter at the peak of activity is to reduce the lag phase as much as possible. Because longer lag phases can bring undesired aromas or weaken the gluten network.
The reason the bacteria are very active at this point is that they don’t have to use energy to get ready to multiply, and they’re not getting dormant or dying at a higher rate because there’s still plenty of nutrients.
A change of environment can be anything that makes the new conditions different from the culture. For example, adding salt to your dough, adding more/less water, adding more/less wholemeal flour, adding sugar, adding fats etc.
The starter passed the peak and it’s collapsing
If your starter has reached the peak and has started to collapse, it means that it’s either at the end of the stationary phase or at the beginning of the death phase already, and it already has accumulated a significant amount of fermentation by-products.
Among these by-products, there are several organic acids responsible for the acidity of the sourdough (lactic acid and acetic acid are the most common). If you used this starter, the fermentation would be slower at the beginning because:
1.- There are less alive bacteria, since many might have died already
2.- The acidification of the starter can inhibit the growth of the bacteria, so the fermentative power will be weaker. The extent of this inhibition depends on how acidic the starter became. That’s why when we try to revive a forgotten starter, it might take a couple of feedings until we see some activity.
3.- The bacteria that are still alive need a longer lag phase before they start growing again. During this lag phase they will get ready for the new environmental conditions (your dough) and will fix the pH of the dough that turned too acidic. And remember, during this phase, bacteria keep producing acids but they’re not reproducing.
Basically, if you don’t control de fermentation, your bread can be very sour. Once again, remember that longer fermentation times not only affect flavor, but also the structure.
Contrary to what many people think, though, you can still use a starter that has passed its peak of activity (by just a few hours) and still obtain a bread that has not soured too much, as long as you control the fermentation.
But.. What if I like my bread very tangy?
The sourness of sourdough bread comes from accumulated organic acids in the dough. So, in order to get the tangy flavor, we need to ensure that the dough has accumulated enough of these compounds.
We can do that by using slightly warmer temperatures during the bulk fermentation. Doing this, the bacteria will be closer to their optimum living conditions, and they will perform a faster fermentation. We could push the bulk a little to get that extra sourness.
How do I know my starter is ready to bake?
There are different ways to check when your starter is ready, and the more familiar you are with it, the easier it’ll be. I’m going to tell you my favorite way to check the peak of activity at home: The height test
I don’t know if this is how people know it, but it’s how I call it. The height test is, in my opinion, the most reliable way for the home baker to check their starter.
If you always feed your starter the same ratios of flour and water, or you build your levain in the same way, this test is great for comparisons; it will be very easy for you to know if it’s ready by just looking at how much it grew. It also prevents the “human factor” more than other tests and reduces the chances of making a mistake.
How to perform the maximum height test
As the name indicates, this test is to see how high the starter can grow (this applies to 100% or less hydration, more liquid starters can’t grow too much, for obvious reasons). The peak of activity coincides with the maximum height.
After reaching the maximum height, the starter will remain at that height for a few hours (stationary phase) before it starts collapsing (beginning of the death phase)
Let’s say you feed your starter with a 1:1:1 starter:water:flour ratio. Then you let it ferment and record the height (taking pictures might be even better!) after it reaches the maximum height you need to pay attention to how long it stays at that height and when it starts collapsing.
Imagine that right after feeding, your starter takes 5 hours to reach the highest height, and then it stays 2 more hours at that height. Those last 2h will be the best period to use your starter.
By doing this simple test, you will see how much your starter grows (double, triple, quadruple?). It’s important to know the temperature when you do this little experiment because in warmer days, your starter will grow faster. However, since you know more or less the highest height it will reach, you just need to keep an eye on it!
Always remember that the time your starter takes to grow will depend on the temperature of your kitchen. Warmer temperatures will make the starter more active because they’re close to their optimum growing temperature. Colder temperatures will make the starter grow slower, because these are far from the optimum conditions.
Let’s wrap this up
I’d like to finish my first Bread Science Fridays by highlighting a few concepts:
1.- Bacterial growth has four phases that can be applied to our sourdough starters. Knowing what happens in each phase will help us understand our starter.
2.- The starter works best when it’s used at its peak of activity because we’re reducing the lag phase and bacteria can use the energy more efficiently.
3.- The maximum height test is an easy experiment to know when a starter reached the peak of activity. It’ll help you understand at which phase your starter is and when it’s best to use.
I hope with today’s post you can understand better your starter and have a better idea of the science behind it! Isn’t the world of sourdough so amazing???
As always, if you ever have any doubts or would like me to talk about the science of something, let me know and I’ll try my best to answer your questions!
You can find me on Instagram or Facebook and you can also subscribe to my Youtube channel.
Happy Bread Science Friday!
Maria